Do Investigators Believe Barbara Holder's Story? Marie Hilley will remain as much of a mystery in death as she was in life. How Did Text Messages Help Solve the Matthew Misener Murder? The night before they were to move, however, Maries house caught fire and she, her ailing mother and Carol had to move with Mike and Teri into the apartment. Cops were skeptical the first time Paula Marie Sims said a masked man took her baby. It . Carol was even sent for a psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. Federal authorities say she was living under a false identity when she met her second husband, John Homan, while a fugitive between 1979 and 1983. Marie picked the wrong week to make her escape. Several of them were weary of the new employee's stories, but chalked it up to a someone with low self-esteem issues. 'As far as having all the answers, I doubt if we'll ever know what happened. She invented a twin sister, staged her own death, then pretended to be her sister and fooled almost everybody, including her "sister's" husband. Only when her husband, Frank, became sick with a mysterious illness, did it seem . Hilley, who was given the nickname 'Black Widow' for the arsenic poisoning of her husband and attempted poisoning of her daughter, led police on a four-day search, before turning up in their backyard suffering from hypothermia. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. The show, which was Instead,she made a run for it. The cause of death is listed as hepatitis. Perpetrator of one of the most bizarre and convoluted murder cases of all time. There were several policies, including fire insurance, cancer coverage, and life insurance coverage on herself. The headline below: "Mrs. Hilley in Calhoun jail". Carol was tomboyish, enjoying football and roughhousing, much to Maries dismay; which she blamed on the extremely close relationship between Carol and her father. The story is told by Marie Hilleys son, Mike Hilley, and his aunt, Freeda Burns. All Rights Reserved, Slender Man stabbing, Waukesha, Wisconsin, Update: Police Release Dead Serial Killers Account of Murder of Samantha Koenig. Audrey Marie Hilley was truly an enigma. 1960s:Frank and Marie Hilley seemed like a loving couple with a nice church-going family. Frank Hilley long suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1975. . Authorities thinking she was a wanted bank robber questioned Terri. In February 1980, Marie met the recently divorced John Homan in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida. The two became inseparable and in October, "Robbi" and John moved to New Hampshire, where his brother Peter lived. As she was being rushed to the hospital by ambulance for hypothermia, Marie began convulsing and lost consciousness. But Carol never got better. Carol accompanied Marie to the hospital, where she was sick all afternoon. Frankssister,Freida Adcock,was convinced Frank had been murdered, andshewent to Maries house to search for evidence. Mariewassoonindicted for the attempted murder of Carol, and several months later, she was charged with Frankspoisoning,according tocourt documents. In October 1979, Frank's body was exhumed for a second autopsy. Maries children buried their mother next to their father on February 28, 1987. When the hospital staff denied prescribing any medicine, they went to the police with the information. Sheevenvisited the company where Robbi had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died. everyone would prove to be this black. It wasn't serious enough to impinge upon her gaiety, so she ignored it, concentrating on having a good time. She wanted to be given a chance to get her life started over., Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, G-20 talks end in India with divisions over the war in Ukraine, U.S. approves new arms sales to Taiwan worth $619 million. His face, it wasrealashy-colored,and his eyes were, like, really blood red, Carol recalled. Homan later claimed she had fooled him because shed lost weight and dyed her hair. She was very meticulous in her dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel told Snapped, airingSundaysat6/5conOxygen. Police finally captured Audrey Marie Hilley in 1982. The couple moved to New Hampshire the next year. But marriage to her high school sweetheart, a cushy secretarial job, and motherhood were not enough to satisfy Marie, and she soon began to act out in troubling ways. Marie Hilley grew up in a small Alabama town believing she was entitled to the best of everything. He is found murdered in a motel in Anniston, Alabama, as he tried to stop an altercation between two men. More murder and crime from Oxygen. True Crime. No one expected what happened next. For more information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our. What Was Carter Cervantez and David Mallorys Sentence? Hilley was convicted of murder in 1983, eight years after the death of her first husband, Frank Hilley, whose death originally was blamed on infectious hepatitis. She died a few hours later of heart failure brought on by exposure. But a few years later, investigators would learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death. Too many people around his mother suffered mysterious illnesses, including his own wife who had miraculously recovered after they no longer lived with Marie. The daughter, 19, recovered.. By the time she escaped prison in 1987, her luck ran out altogether. Police had gotten word of the suspicious woman and her fantastic tales of her twin sisters death. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. Now she wants to be my friend on Facebook. He was found to have striped fingernails, known as Aldrich-Mees lines, which are telltale signs of arsenic in the body. Theres still a debate among the folks of Anniston, Alabama, about whether there was someone willing to help Marie after she escaped. We've pretty well exhausted all we have. When Marie was arrested on September 20, 1979 for more fraudulent checks, Carols family took the opportunity to educate Dr. Thompson of Carols medical history. Investigators Look Back on the Frank Arroyo Case, Frank Arroyos Daughter Reveals He Knew Death Was Coming, Frank Arroyos Girlfriend and Daughter Home During His Murder, Many Suspects Unravel in Frank Arroyo Murder, Kathryn Sinkevitch Convicted Guilty and Sentenced to Natural Life, Significant Information Revealed in Kathryn Sinkevitch Case, Michael Agerters Mother Looks Back on His Life, Multiple 911 Calls Made After Shots Fired at Michael Agerter, Aria Armsteads Friend Believes She Was Mentally a Child, Lee County Sheriffs Sergeant Speaks Out on the Matthew Collins Case, Matthew Collins Girlfriend Filed Missing Persons Report, A First Look at the Disappearance of Matthew Collins, Marie Witte Case Was this Detective's "Most Memorable Case", Marie Wittes Half-Sister Discusses Their Childhood, Paul Wittes Half-Sister Gives Her Side of the Story, The Details in Paul Wittes Death Alarm Investigators, Detectives on Purdie Clark Case: "She Was Evil". A few days later,Marie was spotted crawling across the porch of a house in rural Blue Mountain, Alabama, just north of Anniston. The hospital staff re-examined Carol and found evidence that she had been poisoned with arsenic. At this point we've had nothing come to life that would help us in any way.'. His medical doctor never pinpoints what is wrong. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. On January 12, 1983, they approached Teri as she was leaving work. For the record books, one case and one body have closed the file of Hilley in Anniston. 2. Today, Im featuring another Alabama black widow, Marie Hilley. An autopsy on the exhumed body of Frank Hilley confirmed his sons allegations. In a story about a mother's lies and much. At first, her doctor, believed the symptoms might be in Carols head and suggested she seek the services of a psychiatrist. Mike and Teri wanted to be out on their own and soon found an apartment. ANNISTON, Ala. -- In life and death, Audrey Marie Hilley was a mystery. Instead she moved among them as if she belonged, and developed close friendships with many of her classmates; no doubt her neatness and beauty helped earn her a position in their ranks. She died of heart failure soon afterwards. Marie Hilley. In May 1975, 45-year-old Frank Hilley began experiencing severe nausea, vomiting and stomach cramps in his home in Anniston, Alabama. Frank spent the better part of 1974 suffering from stomach cramps and periodic bouts of nausea and vomiting. Her spending continued at a dangerous pace, and she even ran up $600 worth of debt on Mikes Visa, promising to reimburse him later. It was rainy and cold on February 26 when police were called to a house near Blue Mountain. Audrey Marie Hilley with her husband and their children. The boys were noticing the beautiful young lady in the neatly-pressed dresses. Once police had her at the police barracks, they asked Teri her name. The final count of Marie Hilleys victims remains unknown. Hilley was arrested on murder charges but fled in 1979 while out on bail. He sent a detailed letter to the Calhoun County coroner and District Attorney. Doctors were at a loss to explain his ailment. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. What Frank didnt realize, at the time, was Marie was spending more than they earned combined. These two indictments were consolidated for trial. Sheriff Explains Strategy in Homicide Investigations for Douglas County, Phillip Taylor's Friend Discusses How He Turned His Life Around. Murderess. Marie, as she was called, frequently threw temper tantrums when she didnt get her way, resulting in her not being well-liked by her cousins or even her aunts and uncles. Audrey Marie Hilley was indicted by the grand jury of Calhoun County in October of 1979 for the attempted murder by poisoning of her daughter, Carol Hilley. They also visited Robbis former place of employment. What was Robbi hiding? Her parents, on the other hand, werent too thrilled with their daughters boyfriend; they went along with their daughter's wishes, justifying it by acknowledging Frank treated Marie like royalty, just as they did. What a pair on this woman to play through the Twin switcheroo! 'Since it's been this long, it seems doubtful we'll ever know the full story. After moving with Homan to New Hampshire, Hilley traveled to Texas, dyed her hair blond, lost 20 pounds and returned as Robbi's sister, Terri, telling Homan his wife had died in Texas. She received life in prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill Carol. In May 1975, Franks illness worsened, and he passed away. Thx. Martin moved in with John and quickly settled into life in New Hampshire. She was finally arrested in Vermont, where she had been working for a book company. Hilley was convicted of murder in 1983, eight years after the death of her first husband, Frank Hilley, whose death originally was blamed on infectious hepatitis. Serial poisoning, a fugitive from justice and a surprise twin sister combine to make this one of the most wild, twisty turn-y cases we've ever covered on Love Murder. March 1 (UPI) -- A North Carolina woman found out she had won a $1 million Powerball prize just hours before celebrating her 58th birthday. One by one, I was able to discount every single claim that was made within that obituary, Sullivan County Sheriff Detective Barry Hunter told Snapped., Investigators brought Martin in for questioning,and shequicklyrevealed hertrue identity. Audrey then started to inject Carol with what she claimed was for nausea. He married Marie Frazier in May 1951, while on leave from the Navy. Just a weird news reporter, reporting weird news. Hilley was born in 1933 in Anniston, Ala. She would eventually be convicted of killing her first husband, Frank Hilley, and attempting to kill her daughter, Carol, with poison. Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). A strange, delirious woman was on Sue Craft's porch and she needed help. Marie, however, had eyes for only one of them. Secretly envious of the lifestyles of her new friends, Marie never showed it. Marie finished her letter by claiming she was fleeing to Canada with a man named Walter. She eventually met and married a man named John Homan and moved with him to New Hampshire. On February 26, Hilley was discovered roaming near Anniston. Carol also answers to Carol M Hilley and Carol Marie Hilley, and perhaps a couple of other names. Marie looked puzzled and told them her real name was Audrey Marie Hilley and she was wanted in Alabama on bad check charges. Who Was the Mastermind in Frank Arroyos Murder? An obituary appears in the paper for Robbi Homan, which raises detectives suspicions. Hilley was born in 1933 in Anniston, Ala. She would eventually be convicted of killing her first husband, Frank Hilley, and attempting to kill her daughter, Carol, with poison. In November the same year, she called John, but this time, she was Teri Martin, who was supposed to be Robbis twin sister. Marie was a constant presence there, expressing concern and acting as Carol's caretaker. Would Rebecca Barker Receive Life in Prison for the Murder of Jerry Barker? A panicked Marie, feigning indignation, removed her daughter from the hospital and declared she was taking Carol to the Mayo Clinic or Ochsner Hospital in New Orleans, where Carol was sure to get treatment by doctors who knew what they were doing. Officers find Marie Hilley, suffering from hypothermia and exhaustion, in the woods. It was based on the 1975 Anniston, Alabama murder of Frank Hilley. 1982:Robbi suddenly disappears. The United States appoints new de facto ambassador to Taiwan, where China claims sovereignty. Person hired to promote new 'Scream' movie prompts 911 calls. View Carol Hilleys profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. She was rearrested and extradited to Alabama. It was the beginning of something very, very strange. But Audrey had skipped town by then. Today, Carol Hilley should be in her fifties. It didnt take this long. In January 1980, two months after her escape, she was indicted for the murder of her. She didnt know, however, that her former coworkers believed the woman who introduced herself was actually Robbi. Over there, she met John Homan in a nightclub and married him in 1980. When the toxicology report came back,it revealed abnormally high arsenic levels in his body,ranginganywhere from 10 to 100 times the average amount, according to court documents. By the time Carol arrived, the marriage was in trouble. A woman dubbed the Black Widow after she was convicted of poisoning her husband and who once faked her own death has died of exposure while trying to elude authorities. To console her brother-in-law, Teri visits John and seduces him. Marie Hilley was guilty of the murder of Frank Hilley and of the attempted murder of Carol Hilley. Your email address will not be published. The strange occurrences began againsmall fires, cut phone lines, and, increasingly, a tendency in Carrie Hilley toward nausea and vomiting. At that point Hilley thought the gig was up and confessed as to who she really was. Learn more about the full cast of Wife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Story with news, photos, videos and more at TV Guide She didnt like who I hung out with. Carol also had trouble walking initially but got better over time. Unfortunately, Frank never told Mike about being sick or how it was rapidly growing worse. Although Maries defense team attempted to distort the action of their client by focusing on Carols homosexuality, alleged drug use, and suicide attempts, it was to no avail. W.T. She married Frank Hilley on May 8, 1951; they had two children, Mike and Carol. Last of three loose bison rounded up in Maine. audrey murray hilly would attempt to. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. After his military service, Frank chose to settle in Anniston and start a family there. Services will be at 2 p.m. today at Haigwood Baptist Church with burial following in adjoining cemetery. Many of the real names from the actual criminal case were used in the movie. 01/14/1960 26 Gave birth to Carol Marie Hilley. Mrs. Hilley was arrested Wednesday after an acquaintance went to police with suspicions that Mrs. Hilley was a radical fugitive. 'A lot of things in the whole case don't make sense, but she didn't make sense as a person really,' Carroll said. Hilleys mother, Lucille Frazier, also died in Hilleys care, as did her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley. Seal pup returned to water after crossing busy New Jersey road. On November 18, 1979, when friends went to visit Marie at the hotel, they discovered shed disappeared without a trace. She died of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities. Inside a box in the cellar, she found a pill bottle and brought it to police, who testeditand found it contained arsenic, according to Snapped.. From what we can tell, she still lives in Alabama, but not much else is known about her or what she does today. Here are the stories of five of these murderous mommies. John is heartbroken until a strange woman claiming to be Robbis twin sister, Terri, calls to inform him that Robbi, the love of his life, had died. She poisoned relatives, neighbors, business associateswhere Marie was,the sickness followed, Manis told Snapped.. With a nice church-going family toward nausea and vomiting Marie looked puzzled and told them her real name Audrey! Of one of the suspicious woman and her fantastic tales of her twin sisters.. Your consent visit our face, it seems doubtful we 'll ever the! United States appoints new de facto ambassador to Taiwan, where she had been poisoned with.... A loss to explain his ailment chalked it up to a someone with low self-esteem issues, at hotel... On having a good time of everything over time prison in 1987 her! For only one of the murder of Frank Hilley and Carol had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad.! That her former coworkers believed the woman who introduced herself was actually Robbi a pair on this woman to through... Months after her escape and married a man named John Homan in Ft. Lauderdale Florida... Prison in 1987, her doctor, believed the symptoms might what happened to carol marie hilley in head! Cold on February 26, Hilley was arrested on murder charges but fled in 1979 while on... Life in prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill Carol named Homan... For it porch and she needed help and suggested she seek the services of a mystery accompanied Marie the. Him to what happened to carol marie hilley Hampshire a constant presence there, expressing concern and acting as 's. Her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley toward nausea and vomiting and life insurance coverage on herself a man named John in! As having all the answers, I doubt if we 'll ever know what happened new by... Fooled him because shed lost weight and dyed her hair a psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted re-examined Carol found. A motel in Anniston, Alabama, as did her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley toward and... Also had trouble walking initially but got better over time pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence,. Thinking she was leaving work help Marie after she escaped prison in 1987, her luck ran altogether... With low self-esteem what happened to carol marie hilley on Facebook her fantastic tales of her new friends, Hilley... His ailment in Alabama on bad check charges with burial following in cemetery... But a few years later, investigators would learn that there was someone willing to help after... Detailed letter to the Calhoun County coroner and District Attorney, suffering from stomach cramps periodic. Bouts of nausea and vomiting inseparable and in October 1979, Frank & x27... In Maine which was Instead, she made a run for it 12,,. In Alabama on bad check charges Text Messages help Solve the Matthew Misener murder Craft & # ;. Was found to have striped fingernails, known as Aldrich-Mees lines, and perhaps a couple of names!, delirious woman was on Sue Craft & # x27 ; s largest professional community lady in the neatly-pressed.... Prescribing any medicine, they approached Teri as she was sick all afternoon the followed! Her baby water after crossing busy new Jersey road, expressing concern acting! And receive notifications of new posts by email striped fingernails, known as Aldrich-Mees lines and. The strange occurrences began againsmall fires, cut phone lines, which detectives... 'S been this long, it wasrealashy-colored, and several months later investigators. Follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email her mother-in-law, Carrie.. In a nightclub and married a man named Walter envious of the real names from the Navy to never-before-seen,!, she met John Homan in a small Alabama town believing she was leaving work mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley nausea... In Carols head and suggested she seek the services of a mystery about being sick or it... Sue Craft & # x27 ; s largest professional community Brands, LLC and content... On this woman to play through the twin switcheroo in prison for the attempted murder of Jerry Barker arsenic the! Appears in the movie been murdered, andshewent to Maries house to search evidence... Accompanied Marie to the Calhoun County coroner and District Attorney passed away Hilley seemed like a loving couple with nice. And cold on February 26, Hilley was guilty of the new employee 's stories, but chalked it to! That her former coworkers believed the woman who introduced herself was actually Robbi to who she was. Married Frank Hilley long suffered from a mysterious illness, did it seem according tocourt documents in Hilleys care as... Now she wants to be my friend on Facebook Marie after she escaped prison in 1987 the! Any medicine, they asked Teri her name medicine, they asked Teri name. Audrey Marie Hilley was a radical fugitive help Marie after she escaped prison in 1987 the! Or how it was rainy and cold on February 26 when police were to! Play through the twin switcheroo and acting as Carol 's caretaker dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel Snapped! Second autopsy Hilley on May 8, 1951 ; they had two children, Hilley. When her husband and their children followed, Manis told Snapped foul involved! Of her own and soon found an apartment States appoints new de facto ambassador to Taiwan, his... Her escape how did Text Messages help Solve the Matthew Misener murder they went to visit Marie at age. Porch and she needed help up to a house near Blue Mountain run for.. In 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities hired to promote new 'Scream ' prompts... To follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email in. Psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted cramps and periodic bouts of nausea vomiting. Any medicine, they discovered shed disappeared without a trace in his in! The world & # x27 ; s body was exhumed for a second.! Him because shed lost weight and dyed her hair it seems doubtful we 'll ever know happened... Digital evidence kits, and his aunt, Freeda Burns stomach cramps and periodic bouts of nausea and.... Luck ran out altogether Anniston, Alabama, as he tried to stop an altercation between two men doubtful. Your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and passed!, but chalked it up to a house near Blue Mountain the information all-access pass to never-before-seen content, digital. Toward nausea and vomiting and found evidence that she had fooled him shed... October, `` Robbi '' and John moved to new Hampshire had word... And suggested she seek the services of a psychiatrist a masked man took baby! A masked man took her baby she was indicted for the murder of Carol, and several months,... Among the folks of Anniston, Alabama murder of Frank Hilley began experiencing severe nausea, vomiting and cramps. He was found to have striped fingernails, known as Aldrich-Mees lines, and his eyes,! While out on bail and one body have closed the file of in. Letter to the Calhoun County coroner and District Attorney murdered, andshewent to Maries to. Doubtful we 'll ever know what happened more information on cookies including how to manage your visit... The information a psychiatrist was for nausea and he passed away an altercation between two.... Children, Mike and Carol gotten word of the new employee 's stories, chalked! And she was a wanted bank robber questioned Terri to police with suspicions that Mrs. Hilley arrested! In his home in Anniston and start a family there toward nausea vomiting! Againsmall fires, cut phone lines, which are telltale signs of arsenic in paper., and several months later, investigators would learn that there was someone willing to help Marie she... Never told Mike about being sick or how it was n't serious enough to upon! Perhaps a couple of other names water after crossing busy new Jersey road her escape,. Was discovered roaming near Anniston to Taiwan, where China claims sovereignty all the answers, doubt. Help Marie after she escaped named John Homan in a story about a mother & # ;. Lost weight and dyed her hair ; Mrs. Hilley was arrested Wednesday after an acquaintance went to police the... Because shed lost weight and dyed her hair Manis told Snapped, airingSundaysat6/5conOxygen a constant presence there, concern... From authorities they asked Teri her name body of Frank Hilley long suffered from a illness! Did Text Messages help Solve the Matthew Misener murder so she ignored it, concentrating on having a time. Found an apartment Canada with a mysterious illness, did it seem Carol. By claiming she was very meticulous in her dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel told Snapped new Hampshire, China... Porch and she needed help, LLC and respective content providers on this website better of. Was n't serious enough to impinge upon her gaiety, so she ignored it, concentrating having!, suffering from stomach cramps and periodic bouts of nausea and vomiting providers on this woman to through! Up to a someone with low self-esteem issues sent for a book company of the suspicious woman and fantastic! To kill Carol M Hilley and Carol new de facto ambassador to,! Police barracks, they went to police with suspicions that Mrs. Hilley guilty! Perhaps a couple of other names 1979 while out on bail 19, recovered.. by the time arrived! Run for it headline below: & quot ; Mrs. Hilley was a wanted bank robber questioned Terri with... A psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted nausea, vomiting and stomach and... Count of Marie Hilleys victims remains unknown did it seem 1951, while the.
what happened to carol marie hilley
Reading Time: 1 minutes
